Animation Source Forums

I've been wondering, whose the stronger demon here? Red isn't the real devil, he's said to be working for a bigger power which dragged him back to Hell in the end. Now, Red had bigger motives, but he didn't show much in the means of power outside collars and sucking an island down to Hell, which he may have not done himself. Belladonna has some degree of reality warping powers and seemed to be the counterpart to Anabelle's rank for 'The Other Side', and Anabelle is the Archangel. So I personally think Belladonna is the bigger bad than Red. What do you guys think?

I think Belladonna, I don't have a degree in demonology, but just a theory, Red could have been-or was working for a higher power than himself, so when he failed to get the horn in the second movie, he got punished for it, and took Carface with him. Belladonna = Anabelle's cousin, so she could have been a high ranking angel fallen from heaven. Red might have been a monster/torture type demon, than a full on master of darkness.

Yeah. That's my logic too. And also, in the third movie, it took having an entire snow bank dropped on Belladonna to stop her when just a little water hurt Red. That and she's shown to have some degree of reality warping abilities, which shows she's stronger than Red since he lacked them.

i agree with belladonna being the better demon then red. cause red didn't do much and i didn't like him. not one bit. belladonna did a lot more and was better at doing evil things better then that dumb red did.

belladona is the bomb she is way stronger then red and is actually of the same class of demon as saten himself so yeah give her points there

and belladonna did alot more schemes then red too.

i think Red is the strongest because he is more manipulative than belladonna and charlie doesn't know hes a devil cat until like near the end of the movie and belladonna got killed by snow, red by falling and the horn, red can endure more than belladonna

I'd say Red wins as an overall villain. But if I were looking for one to illustrate the basic nature of demons to someone unfamiliar with such matters, I would choose Belladonna because of her history. It's made evident enough that she was an angel at one point, and decided to rebel, which is essentially what a demon is.

I agree with the above. Belladonna is an evil that exists. Therefore, Belladonna, and is central to the Dog Hell. But if we take any of them more powerful, then I get lost.

I definetly half to say Red. Belledona is waaay to anoying. She never stops laughing. Red is way more cool. So yeah Red. Belladona stinks.

Belladonna personality-wise.
Red design-wise.
I chose 'Belladonna.

We all got to know and see more of her; and yet we only saw Red appear in 30-45 minutes of the whole ADGTH movie total?

I truthfully hate them both completely I'm on Anabelle's side if anything call me a angel, but i am not the perfect angel

While I would claim the same alliance as you, I think the question is which was more formidable as a villain(ess).

Belladonna was my favorite evil whippet character in All Dogs Go to Heaven the Series since I like using her in my fan fiction story I created "Haunted Mansion the Movie" based off the Disneyland and Walt Disney World dark ride attraction in which I have Bella assisting Charlie, Itchy, Bess, Sasha, Anne Marie, David, Mike and Johnny "FNAF the Golden Years Audio Drama on YouTube" as they find themselves trapped inside a rundown abandoned mansion during a thunderstorm, escorted by their unseen Ghost Host while looking for another way out. In the end of the story it is Bella defeating her so-called boss Red in a test of strength brawl as dragons with Belladonna as the Maleficent Dragon from the Disney animated film "Sleeping Beauty" and Red as the red female dragon from the "Shrek" movies and Charlie KOs Red like Bruce Lee with a flying sidekick shouting "Mortal Kombat!"

In the story, that is if or when you get a chance to see it for yourself, when it gets posted of course...Belladonna has a crush on Johnny the young twin brother of Mike when he (Johnny) believes the witch whippet is not bad or evil but has kindness-goodness inside her instead and they become friends just like that with Annabelle congratulating her twin sibling for seeing the light too.

In case you don't know who I am, I am "Space Ace" the animated character of the Don Bluth laser-disc animated video game "SPACE ACE" which was a sequel to his previous laser-disc animated videogame "DRAGON's LAIR"