Animation Source Forums

yeah even when her pride turned on her and she still wanted to kill Simba and Kiara, and make Kovu king isnt really as great as compared to the events that Scar went through. He had a lot of hyenas to help him take over the kingdom. but that was the second thign on his list of things to do. he first minipulated Simba that he was the one that killed Mufasa. Then Scar wanted Simba killed, even though he didnt die. BUt he still assumed that the hyenas finished the task. So then he went on to Pride Rock and took over. Yes, he starved the hyenas, slashed Sarabi and fought Simba. My opinion still stands as Scar having more evil. And when your thinking about it, think about the lengths he went through to get to be king. Zira wanted to just kill Simba and Kiara and make the heir to Scar (A.K.A. Kovu) to be king like Scar once was.

I think Zira because she was just soo controling although Scar was pretty evil

It's a very close call to me..For one, Scar was a depraved tyrant who nearly drove his own kingdom into ground.Zira was an insane widow who would go to any lengths to avenge Scar.......But in the end I'd pick Scar..

agree

I'd have to say neither. They're evil for a reason and there's ALWAYS a reason.

Scar wasn't always evil that much I know. In my opinion he was must've been poorly mistreated by his family including Mufasa.

Zira's name means hate so can you honestly say that she was evil from the start. Is there proof of that? No. Something must've happened to make them evil.

Scar may have hated Mufasa but did you ever stop to think that maybe Mufasa hated Scar for some reason? Perhaps a relationship with Sarabi maybe?

Zira loved Scar very much and would do anything to defend his legacy.

The fact that Simba, after throwing his uncle off the large top of Pride Rock, seeing the hyenas make their move on him, ready to tear him to pieces, yes Scar killed Mufasa and tried to kill him but Scar is of Simba's blood, the royal blood. You think if he would've had any ounce of some remorse, sympathy, anything he would've called the hyenas off but he didn't do it. In truth Simba is as much of a murderer as Scar.

Zira,Her sin would obviously be greed and lust.She was tempted by pride and anger,
but then again, who could blame her? However, at the end her sanity was basically
lost and basically she became bloodthirsty.Greed then set in and she couldn't conrol
it.When she finally gained her sanity is was too late.In my opinion, her domain and
where she lived caused her to lose her sanity along time ago in the movie...however,
this indeed is just my opinion

I voted Scar yea Zira did some horibble things, but I think Scar did much worse

Yeah , voted for zira

i think zira because she wanted to kill all of the pridelanders and started a war..scar didnt

scar, he is a real bad

Zira, because she manipulated her own children into to doing the dirty work.