Animation Source Forums

Scar. He was the one who did all of the evil things in the first place. I believe Zira was sane all until Simba killed Scar. Then she went freakin' nuts.

Scar has more evil...Zira only want to revenge Scar...

I definitely agree with this one. Scar is definitely the most evil of all the TLK characters.

Well... Im not quite sure now. From what i been reading. I think that Zira kill Simba's cub, Kopa. At first i thought he ran away (Still not sure). But im now kind of pulling to the fact that Zira killed Kopa. If that is true the way Disney made it. Then i think that Zira Is now quite as evil or more then Scar.

Zira may have let evil roam her life and died in the place of Scar.She never wanted to go to the good side and turn her back on Scar.But still,Scar murdered Mufassa,told Simba it was all his fault,and told him to run away so he could make himself king,*takes deep breath*I came to Scar as the evilest one.

I vote Scar. But I like Zira better as a villain. Zira was 'crazier' than Scar, but Scar was 'nastier'.

I'd have to say Scar, like the others said, he killed his brother, atempted on killing his nephew, and Nala, he didn't care about the Pridelands, he let the Pridelands die, and let the Hyenas take it over, like what Nala said to Simba when she FOund him, Nala:Simba, He let the Hyenas take over the Pridelands. he would've done worse in my opinion. And also for the fact he let all his lionesses starve, some may have died, he backstabbed the hyenas and futhermore he has been trying to make Simba confess a crime that Simba did not commit.

But that doesn't change my feelings for him, He is my Favorite character

Also, although I did vote Scar, you can't say Scar was more evil because he murdered. Zira tried to use her son to murder Simba, and if you'll recall the song 'My Lullaby' she was happy to see Nala and Kiara suffer.

But I still think Zira was less evil because, unlike Scar, she showed love. She did love Kovu, but was blinded by her hate. And she loved Nuka (and Vitani) but you didn't see how she loved Nuka until he died.

zira

Scar. He actually killed someone and made the rest of the pride suffer. Plus he tried to act friendly around Simba to win his trust and then eventually stick the knife in his back when Simba finds out that it was Scar who killed Mufasa.

Zira, bitter and using Kovu to try and kill Simba but she showed love: she grieved when Nuka was killed. She didn't make the pride of lionesses suffer, unlike Scar.

i really think scar ahs more evil who would kill their own brother just for power and they were best friends while cubs

I voted Scar, he actually killed.

I'd say both but I chose Scar.

Scar committed murder, starved the lionesses, lied to his nephew, and tried to eat Zazu(nobody mentioned that!)

Zira was pushy, trained her own kids for killing others, and was more "DO THIS NOW" than attacking herself. In my opinion, Zira is like a drill Sargent. She more commanding than actually helping the others.

And Scar actually had just a little bit more evil. He killed his brother and lied to Simba just to take the throne. He starved the lionesses for the hyenas. Scar was more evil but still I say both are evil

zira is bad